1. Could this novel have convincingly taken place in a contemporary setting? How would it change? How would it remain the same?

2. How might Chance, Emma, and John each define love? Are they truthful to themselves about how they feel concerning love? Through which of their actions do you draw your opinions and why?

3. Was Emma's desire to become a "better person" a sincere and altruistic resolution? In its inception could it have been sincere but also selfish?

4. Did you identify with any of the characters while reading Vertigo? Were you sympathetic to them?

5. Does Emma own her choices? When making decisions, does she act independently or unknowingly as a puppet? How much of the course of her life and her identity is a result of manipulation (by her father, husband, lover…)?

6. Discuss the role of identity in Vertigo. How do identities evolve or develop? How are they disguised or revealed? Is identity something that is self-created or does it exist externally? Are personality and an individual's character autonomous developments or the result of reflected perception?

7. Is Emma a victim? What role does she play in victimization? If she herself is not a victim, what is it about her character that makes her guilty of victimizing others?

8. Katherine, Emma's niece, runs away to live in poverty with a man whom she loves in order to escape the limitations placed on her by her family. Do you think that the social pressures placed on women during the Victorian era were unique?

9. Do you believe that Emma's childhood trauma was a justification for her actions later in life? Do you think she believed this was so?

10. Constance's husband deals with their marital problems by banishing her from their social circle. John largely ignores the problems in his marriage to Emma, but also punishes her through manipulation. What are the fundamental similarities and differences between Constance and Emma in their reactions to their husbands' domination?

11. Why do the other women in this novel seem so content with their lives despite their complaints and gossip? Do you think they really are?

12. What are the motivations behind Chance's late confession to Emma?

13. What is the basis of the relationship between Emma’s father and John? Why doesn’t Emma’s father stand up for his daughter in court? What would you have done if you were in his shoes?

14. Do John's actions partially lead to his own downfall?

15. The last line of the novel, "After all, we each of us make our own chances," is obviously a play on words. What do you think: Do we make our own chances, or does chance make us?

16. The novel is open-ended. What do you imagine happens to Emma and Chance after the last chapter?