1. The title of this novel has been changed from its original, The Taking, to Artist of the Beautiful, which is taken from the title of a Nathaniel Hawthorne short story.Why do you think the title was changed? Which title: a) do you prefer, and b) do you think more appropriate?

2. In previous drafts of Artist of the Beautiful, some characters had different names: Sarianna was Susannah; Jeremy Treat was Darius Scadding; Una Treat was Alma Scadding; Simeon was Jairus. Why do you think these individual names might have been changed? Discuss how important you think characters' names are in this or any novel.

3. In what ways does the author "see --- New Englandly?" Consider not only landscape and history but also temperament.

4. What might the author mean when he says in the preceding interview, "We become those we love, and those we kill"? How does this relate to Artist of the Beautiful?

5. The lyrics of all but one of the songs and hymns in this novel were written by the author. Which one was not? (Hint: It was translated from the Italian.)

6. Describe Sarianna Renway's physical appearance. Why do you think her image sometimes fails to appear in mirrors and never appears in photographs? Discuss the use of both mirrors and photographs in this novel.

7. How many times in her life does Sarianna have sex? The author describes her as "asexual." Sarianna says early in the novel (p. 16) that she feels privileged to have been freed of desire before she was "lashed" by it. Discuss the use of the word "lashed" in two of its meanings: to be "bound" and to be "whipped." What does Sarianna mean when she says, "Without an object, desire is not only aimless but incongruous"? What happens to Sarianna when she encounters people she does desire? How does she function in an atmosphere so sexually charged?

8. When Sarianna finds on a Mount Holyoke College bulletin board the advertisement for the tutoring job in the Swift River Valley, she tears it down "so no one else might see it." How much of a schemer is Sarianna? How much of a coquette? Discuss what she learns about herself in the course of this one summer, keeping in mind that she is looking back upon this time from over fifty years later.

9. Do you think that Ethan is frozen in time, or is time frozen in Ethan? Why does Ethan's hair suddenly begin to grow after more than ten years?

10. What does Una mean when she says, "There is no now"? Is there indeed such a thing as the present moment? How does Una's statement relate to this novel, particularly to the revelation in the epilogue when Ethan's coffin is opened? What happens in the novel that makes Sarianna contradict Una's pronouncement?

11. Emily Dickinson wrote that Jesus was "too trackless for a tomb." How might this relate to the discovery of Ethan and Una, together and young, at the end of the book?

12. Jeremy Treat "wrestled not with the triviality of God but with the enormity of man." Sarianna has come to believe, through the example of Emily Dickinson, "If God made man, He was imperfect; if man made God, he was divine." A sign in the novel states, "God has no religion." Discuss these statements and this novel as a religious novel. Do you think God has, or favors, a particular religion? Do you think God ever intervenes in human affairs? Discuss the notion of "free will" in the novel (see p. 122), particularly as it relates to that of God's will.

13. Is any book in which there are characters who believe in God a book that therefore deals in the supernatural?

14. In what ways is Jimmy "the perfect representation of God on earth"? What does Jeremy Treat mean when he says, "If God were an artist, my son is what He'd make"?

15. Who is the "artist of the beautiful"? Ethan? Jimmy? Sarianna? Emily Dickinson? God? Any and all of us?

16. As a person and/or artist, would you rather be renowned when alive and forgotten when dead or unknown when alive and immortal when dead?